Yes, I know that buying a book all about Europa makes me a traitor... I know, I know...
Link: Europa (University of Arizona Space Science Series) (Hardcover) [www.amazon.com]
...for now we have not one planet only revolving about another, while both traverse a vast orbit about the Sun, but our sense of sight presents us four stars circling about Jupiter, like the Moon about the Earth...The Starry Messenger
- From Galileo's Sidereus Nuncius (trans. by Edward S. Carlos)
As Galileo recorded his observations of the Jovian system in the first two months of 1610, Galileo set about writing a book reporting his discoveries to the world. This book, Sidereus Nuncius or The Starry Messenger in English, was approved for publication by the Venetian church censors on March 1, completed on March 2 with one final Jovian observation, religious approval formalized on March 8 (probably after the proofs), and published on March 12 with a new forward dedicated to the Grand Duke of Tuscany. Also during this time, he changed his suggested naming for the four new moons from the Cosmica Sidera (or the Cosmic Stars after Grand Duke Cosimo personally) to Medicea Sidera, or the Medicean Stars after Florence's ruling family as a whole. All of these flatteries, the dedicated forward, the naming of the moons after the Medici, and the special bound version along with one of Galileo's telescopes sent to Cosimo through Tuscany's ambassador to Venice, Belisario Vinta, were intended to get in Cosimo's good graces, perhaps with a post at the University of Pisa and a better deal than the Venetians had given him in return.
Much of the opposition to Galileo's discoveries came from the lack of verifiability. With telescopes of high enough power to observe Jupiter's moons so rare, other astronomers were having difficulty replicating his discoveries, except for Simon Marius, but he didn't publish his findings for another four years. Kepler finally had a high-enough powered telescope by October 1610, and was able to confirm the existence of Jupiter's moons. The Jesuit astronomer of the Collegio Romano Christopher Clavius in Rome first disputed Galileo's findings for lack of proper instrumentation, but finally observed them as well by December 1610. Other observers of the Galilean satellites during that second observing season included Thomas Harriot in England as well as Nicolas-Claude Fabri de Peiresc and Joseph Gaultier de la Vallette in France. de Peiresc would later suggest individual names for the Galilean moons based on the names of Cosimo and his brothers, but those have not survived to the modern day.
Galileo would persist in his support for a heliocentric universe, as most dramatically presented in his 1632 book, Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems. In that book, Galileo presented arguments for both the Copernican heliocentric model and the Tychonic hybrid model. His attempt to be balanced in his coverage, as requested by Pope Urban VIII, a friend of Galileo's prior to his elevation to the papacy, backfired however, when it was perceived as having mostly pushed the heliocentric view, correcting the points of the geocentric Simplicio, and insulting his former friend, the Pope. This apparent outright defense of the Copernican world view was seen as in violation of an order by Cardinal Roberto Bellarmino in 1616 (who was later canonized in 1930), which ordered him to only describe the heliocentric universe as a theory. While it is now agreed that Galileo didn't intend to slight the pope (and Simplicio was meant not as an insult, but as a reference to famous Aristotelian philosopher Simplicius), Galileo's apparent offense to the Pope, who was already seen as not being tough enough against heretics, removed the huge support he had against his church critics. For his support of the Copernican heliocentric world view and his support of atomism (the view that matter was composed of small, invisible particles, which contradicted the transubstantiation of the Eucharist), he was put on trial for heresy in Rome. Galileo was found guilty, but managed to avoid life imprisonment or worse by confessing his actions and refuting his earlier heliocentrism. As a result of this and his age, Galileo would receive house arrest, requiring him to remain at his Villa il Gioiello in Arcetri near Florence.Then for the first time I looked at Jupiter, who was in opposition to the Sun, and made out some tiny stars, sometimes following, sometimes preceding Jupiter in a straight line with him. First, I thought that they were of the number of those fixed stars ... However, as Jupiter was then retrograding, and still I saw these stars accompanying him throughout December, I was at first much astonished; but by degrees arrived at the following view, namely, that these stars moved round Jupiter, just as the five solar planets revolve round the Sun.Meanwhile, in Germany...
- Simon Marius in the Mundus Jovialis (1614)
In late 1608, as news of the Dutch discovery of the telescope spread across Europe, one of the inventors traveled to Frankfort in an attempt to market it. The news of an instrument that made "the most distant objects be seen as though quite near" caught the attention of John Philip Fuchs, Lord Privy Councilor to the Margraves of Brandenburg-Ansbach. He attempted to buy the telescope from the Dutch glass maker. While he was allowed a demonstration of it, he found the price unacceptable. Upon his return to Ansbach, Fuchs met with the court astronomer, Simon Marius (latinized from Simon Mayr), and they attempted to fashion their own telescope, but their were unable to get a working model since they didn't know how to polish glass and the lens makers in nearby Nuremberg didn't have the right tools. By the summer of 1609, enough copies of the telescope were being made in the Netherlands that the prices had come down substantially since Fuchs first attempt to buy one the previous autumn. With a newly purchased telescope, Simon Marius set to work making astronomical observations with it from both the home of the Lord Privy Councilor and at Marius's home at the Ansbach Observatory.
Simon Marius's treatise on his observations of the Jupiter system (as well as sunspots), Mundus Iovialis, was published in 1614, which included the first table of predicted positions for the satellites. In his book, Marius acknowledged Galileo as the discoverer of the new worlds of Jupiter, "The credit, therefore, of the first discovery of these stars in Italy is deservedly assigned to Galileo and remains his." Clearly, one could make the argument that he is quibbling when he says that Galileo was the discoverer IN ITALY, while he was the German discover of the moons. Marius's supporters in Germany would later try to make the further claim that Marius was the sole discoverer, beating Galileo.Now four years after my Sidereus Nuncius appeared, this same fellow [Simon Marius] (in the habit of trying to ornament himself with other people's works) unblushingly made himself the author of the things I had discovered and printed in that book. Publishing under the title of Mundus Iovialis, he had the gall to claim that he had observed the Medicean planets which revolve about Jupiter before I had. But note his sly way of attempting to establish his priority. I had written of making my first observation on the seventh of January, 1610. Along comes Marius, and, appropriating my very observations, he prints on the title page of his book (as well as in the opening pages) that he had made his observations in the year 1609. But he neglects to warn the reader that he is a Protestant, and hence had not accepted the Gregorian calendar. Now the seventh day of January, 1610, for us Catholics, is the same as the twenty-eighth day of December, 1609, for those heretics. And so much for his pretended priority of observation.So Galileo clearly took offense, despite Marius's attempt in Part 1 of Mundus Iovialis to relieve that possible tension.
Jupiter is much blamed by the poets on account of his irregular loves. Three maidens are specially mentioned as having been clandestinely courted by Jupiter with success. Io, daughter of the River Inachus, Callisto of Lycaon, Europa of Agenor. Then there was Ganymede, the handsome son of King Tros, whom Jupiter, having taken the form of an eagle, transported to heaven on his back, as poets fabulously tell, and notably Ovid. I think therefore, that I shall not have done amiss if the First is called by me Io, the Second Europa, the Third, on account of its majesty of light, Ganymede, the Fourth Callisto.For Tomorrow
On Monday, I received my copy of the book Volcanism on Io: A Comparison with Earth by JPL researcher Ashley Davies. This book, by Cambridge University Press, was published late last year. I had considered picking up a copy since it was published, but the cost of the book ($133 on Amazon.com) was a significant barrier. Thankfully due to some lowered expenses this month, I was able to pull the trigger on buying this book.
Well I finally pulled the trigger on this book and ordered it on Amazon last week. Volcanism on Io: A Comparison with Earth by Ashley Davies is a comprehensive overview of the current state of knowledge into the volcanism displayed on the surface of Io. An overview of terrestrial volcanism and remote sensing studies is provided as a background to better understand what we see on Io.
Welcome to The Gish Bar Times, the only blog dedicated to Jupiter's volcanic moon, Io!